Anatomy of a Throne: “The Gift”

HBO’s Game of Thrones (typically, and before this current season) brandishes a consistent and high degree of fidelity to the nearly 5,000-page-long source material of George R.R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire novels, but there still, of course, are differences. While most of these gaps from the page to the screen are small and detail-oriented, it is nonetheless the case that the most subtle discrepancies often hold the biggest insight into the adaptation process, into the demands of filmmaking, and into the rigors of the literary narrative.

This, then, is the anatomy of a key scene of Thrones – not because of its dramatic importance or visual effects whizbangery, but because of the telling nature of its realization.

Episode: “The Gift” (507)
Scene: Sam’s first time

Warning: there is material in this article that some may regard as spoilers, given that chapters from the books are discussed in depth, and some of the elements from them may yet appear in future episodes. Proceed with caution.

Sam in bed

In a season full of considerably huge deviations, one of the biggest changes is the trajectory of Samwell Tarly’s character arc (though it still, of course, manages to hit many – if not most – of the same destinations along the way). Indeed, the lead-up to the scene where he forswears his Night’s Watch vows and sleeps with Gilly, Craster’s former wife/daughter, is not only unrecognizable in its visual form, it also is highly telling of showrunners David Benioff and Dan Weiss’s different foci as storytellers – for both good and ill.

In A Feast for Crows, neither Sam nor Gilly is even at the Wall. Jon Snow (who was elected lord commander far earlier in the novels) makes the rather extreme decision to dispatch those characters who are the most likely to fall victim to Lady Melisandre’s pyromaniacal ways: King-beyond-the-Wall Mance Rayder’s newborn son (who, obviously, is wholly absent from the HBO series) and Maester Aemon Targaryen, the man who was almost a king 65 years previously (he had his brother, Egg, crowned in his stead). Gilly is forced to trade out her own newborn babe for Mance’s and escort him down south to Oldtown, with Sam leading the ragtag band. Once there, Samwell is to see the wildling girl safely deposited at his family’s castle, while he himself will train to become a maester at the Citadel, to assist – and, eventually, replace – the ailing Aemon.

(Two items of note regarding this particular storyline from the books. Firstly, the idea of Melisandre wanting to sacrifice even more royal offspring does, indeed, get carried over to Game of Thrones, though here it takes the form of Stannis’s very own daughter, the princess Shireen [which moves the conflict regarding such a proposition from Lord Commander Snow to King Baratheon]. Secondly, Sam’s being sent to Oldtown is actually a development of some note for the character, given that he has been behaviorally conditioned to be revolted by the very idea of joining the maesters’ order; when Sam mentioned that very possibility to his father as a youth, Lord Randyll Tarly responded by chaining him by the neck to a cell wall for three days. Omitting this little slice of backstory and characterization both is probably just as much a result of Sam’s different personality – he’s nowhere near as craven on the show as he is in the novels, which might make such previous treatment stick out like a sore thumb [no pun intended] – as it is a product of time constraints.)

Maester Aemon

On the journey south, Aemon quickly perishes, with the old man remarking that he should’ve realized that the cold of the Wall had helped preserve him for his 102 years. And since he dies on a Summer Isles vessel, the crew insists on following their own customs for dealing with the loss of a revered elder: celebrating. “Black Sam said good words,” one of the ship’s mates tells him. “Now we drink his life.”

And drink they do – casks of spiced rum, which is the very first time that either Sam or Gilly has had the exotic beverage. Between his sorrow, the unbearable responsibility of his mission, the fear of his Citadel future, and, of course, the copious amounts of rum, Sam finds himself swept off his feet, metaphorically if not literally. Once they’re finally done drinking, he helps Gilly down to the women’s quarters in the bow of the Cinnamon Wind, where things quickly get out of hand:

There was a lantern hanging just inside the cabin, and he managed to bang his head on it going in. “Ow,” he said, and Gilly said, “Are you hurt? Let me see.” She leaned close…

…and kissed his mouth.

Sam found himself kissing her back. I said the words, he thought, but her hands were tugging at his blacks, pulling at the laces of his breeches. He broke off the kiss long enough to say, “We can’t,” but Gilly said, “We can,” and covered his mouth with her own again. The Cinnamon Wind was spinning all round them and he could taste the rum on Gilly’s tongue and the next thing her breasts were bare and he was touching them. I said the words, Sam thought again, but one of her nipples found its way between his lips. It was pink and hard and when he sucked on it, her milk filled his mouth, mingling with the taste of rum, and he had never tasted anything so fine and sweet and good. If I do this, I am no better than [a traitor], Sam thought, but it felt too good to stop. And suddenly his cock was out, jutting upward from his breeches like a fat pink mast. It looked so silly standing there that he might have laughed, but Gilly pushed him back onto her pallet, hiked her skirts up around her thighs, and lowered herself onto him with a little whimpery sound. That was even better than her nipples. She’s so wet, he thought, gasping. I never knew a woman could get so wet down there. “I am your wife now,” she whispered, sliding up and down on him. And Sam groaned and thought, No, no, you can’t be, I said the words, I said the words, but the only word he said was, “Yes.”

Knowing that the vast majority of this storyline would be jettisoned, Weiss and Benioff had a two-prong approach to still keep Sam and Gilly on the same ultimate destination. Sam’s growing affection for Craster’s daughter was pushed to the foreground – yet another sizable difference from the source material in and of itself – right from the very beginning, when Gilly is first introduced (“The North Remembers,” episode 201); indeed, at one point, Dolorous Edd openly refers to Samwell as a “man in love” (“Valar Morghulis,” 210), and, two seasons later, he gets to openly prove it by kissing Gilly before heading off into battle (“The Watchers on the Wall,” 409).

The kiss

More pointedly, a whole new set of circumstances in the wake of Maester Aemon’s death had to be drummed up in order to get the pair off their emotional bearings and to bring them physically close together. The tack chosen, of course, was violence – more specifically, the threat of sexual assault, which has been a default narrative device that the showrunners have turned to time and again since nearly day one, from Theon Greyjoy’s proposed punishment for trying to escape the Dreadfort (“Walk of Punishment,” 303) to, most infamously (and recently), Sansa Stark’s wedding night (“Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken,” 506). From a purely pragmatic, storytelling perspective, it is easy to see why such a practice would be instituted: violence is one of several elements that translates especially well to the visual medium, and rape, specifically, has been built into the very fabric of Westerosi society by George R.R. Martin himself. It also, on the screen, demonstrates the perpetual, ominous threat that hangs over Westeros’s denizens (especially the women) in a much more direct way than Martin’s meandering traipses through the countryside do.

The black brothers’ attempts to sexually attack Gilly also perhaps serves another narrative function. At the time of its airing last year, Jon Snow’s expedition back to Craster’s keep in order to bring those mutineers who murdered both Craster and Jeor Mormont to justice (“First of His Name,” 405) was seen as little more than filler, given that Jon’s ascension to lord commander was so delayed – and injecting more violence and nudity into the series can always, generally speaking, be considered a patent bonus, to boot. Now, it may perhaps be considered at least a partial bit of foreshadowing, establishing the notion that Gilly will not be able to escape her sisters’ fate for long (exactly how Jon’s discovery of Craster’s sacrificial offerings to the White Walkers [“The Night Lands,” 202] ended up playing a direct role in his deceiving of Mance Rayder [“Valar Dohaeris,” 301]). The move also, obviously, allows Sam a chance to demonstrate his increasing bravery and newfound sense of courage in a way that is both more succinct and blatant than the character’s slow and halting progression in Feast for Crows, killing two ravens with one stone.

Gilly in bed

For all of this, however, the lovemaking scene itself plays rather similarly, with the only real – albeit subtle – difference being that the printed page’s version is steamier (no bared breasts or mother’s milk here) while the television show’s depiction is more humorous, with Sam making the “whimpery sound,” followed by the perfectly-in-character “Oh, my.”

A lack of passion, one can surmise, is the price to be paid for more competent and far less awkward characters.

Previous installments

“The Wars to Come” (501)

“High Sparrow” (503)

“Sons of the Harpy” (504)

“Kill the Boy” (505)

“Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken” (506)

15 responses

Jump to (and Always Support) the Bottom

    1. Drakoen,

      I’m pretty sure Sam’s travel to Oldtown will begin (and maybe even end) by the end of this season. They didn’t set up Oldtown and the Citadel in that library conversation between Sam and Gilly just for shits and giggles, especially considering this is season five —there’s no room left for useless exposition. Aemon dying will lead to Sam being sent to the Citadel to substitute him as Castle Black’s maester.

      I don’t blame them for wanting to maximize Sam and Jon’s time together. In the books, Sam comes back after the Battle of Castle Black, and he is sent away by Jon not long after. In the show, thanks to a couple of timeline differences, Sam and Jon have had two whole seasons together. A welcome change, in my opinion.

        Quote  Reply

    2. I personally found the scene logical.

      Without Jon and his allies, the real face of the Watch emerges… a band or rapists and murderers…

      GRRM never really wrote on that and I always had a weird feeling in the books that “oh, yeah, all this scums behave and try to have a decent second chance.”

      But to readress that issue in the show was a nice move… unleashed, an important part of the brothers are just assholes. So their attempt to assault Gilly was a logical development now that Jon is absent.

      And I’m pretty sure it will give Sam and Gilly the definitive kick to get South asap… especially now that Aemon’s dead. It will give the perfect excuse to Jon to send them to safety.

      Still I’m sad we wont get to see Ghost at Hardhome ! Here’s to the hope that some direwolves will show up there !

        Quote  Reply

    3. Hello Marc,

      I have forbidden my software developers from reading your posts at work. They tend to go on long breaks after reading them. How dare you discuss fat pink masts and milky breasts while we are trying to develop new parsing algorithms!

        Quote  Reply

    4. I am more interested in knowing the fate of the evil Ramsay snow/ Bolton. He treats Sansa Stark like a whore, and in the presence of the weak Theon Grayjoy, who is not fit at all to be a a warrior. I really want to know who, you guys think will be the demise of the evil incarnate.

        Quote  Reply

    5. Arkash: Without Jon and his allies, the real face of the Watch emerges… a band or rapists and murderers…

      Exactly. As soon as Stannis and his troops departed, then Jon, Edd and a few decent others, and Aemon died, it was very clear at Aemon’s funeral that the Watchers left were really the scum of the earth and the Wall was absolutely no place for one lone woman. Many decent Watchers had passed away in earlier seasons, including most of Sam’s group.
      I wonder what this says about the long-term future of the Watchers, or the Wall.

        Quote  Reply

    6. Thanks Marc for another great piece!

      I agree with Luka Nieto, a lot of namedrops about the Citadel, Sam saying he wanted to be a Maester, there is still time (either now or in S6) for Oldtown to happen! Also Sam’s up shit creek at CB since as Alliser Thorne has pointed out- he has no friends left.
      It would make sense post-Hardhome, Jon returns, finds Maester Aemon has died, and sends Sam to train to replace him.
      Departure for Oldtown before the end of the season would allow Sam to be away during FTW if it happens.
      And it’s looking slightly more likely we’ll see the Reach next year (maybe a Gilly dropoff?) since one of the new casting calls sounds like Sam’s Dad Randyll Tarly!

        Quote  Reply

    7. I think people are very short sighted when they speak of a scene(s) or events that have happened in the book but not yet in the show and assume they’re cut. D&D push MANY story lines/characters back a season in the show so they aren’t forcing lots of new stuff on the audience each season. Sam is CLEARLY GOING TO THE CITADEL NEXT SEASON and we’ll be getting to see his dad as well. Not going off the casting calls (which all but confirms it) but Randall Tarly has been mentioned lots in the past and at least once this season, and the Citadel got name dropped not once but TWICE in the same scene. Also, they briefly touched on Sam becoming a maester all in the same scene as the other name drops (scene where Gilly is talking to Sam and then Stannis comes in). It was obvious that the iron born plot would be pushed back and not scrapped all together, though we suspect it will be streamlined and have no idea yet how much will be cut but we’ll at the very least get Euron with his introduction being a super streamlined version of book events and likely get more book stuff w/ regards to Balon. Makes sense if you know how D&D’s adapting mind/process works that they are just saving Balon’s source material so we would see the immediate aftermath of it. GUARANTEE YOU WE GET THE SAM BEING CHAINED BY HIS DAD STORY NEXT SEASON. They push back little stories like that ALL THE TIME AS WELL.

        Quote  Reply

    8. Also I love what they’re doing this season to streamline the books. Many people will complain because the book readers love to complain about any differences and this season has the most, but what D&D are doing is making the best, most entertaining season possible using the book story as a guideline. I’m a book reader but I see that they ARE being as faithful as possible with the books and are still following the book path except in a remixed way. Book readers, if they followed the books exactly or near exactly then half of the events we’ve witnessed this season would not have happened yet, we’d get a much more dragged out (yet still interesting and well done but way more slower burn) version of half of this seasons events with less high points, we’d get Brienne’s boring storyline wandering around the Riverlands (at least they aren’t wasting pointless screen time with her this season, likely she gets good stuff to do at the end), Jon’s storyline would also be much more slow burn with no action, Cersai would be plotting still and fuckin the Kettlebecks and making friends with small pointless characters while having a lesbian like relationship. Tyrion’s storyline this season would likely have ended with him getting captured by Jorah and not seeing Dany, Sansa would be sitting at the Vale all season doing nothing but getting convinced by Littlefinger to marry Harry the heir(who will be a weaker version of Ramsay/Jofferey guaranteed) and fuck him to combine house Stark and the Vale. Littlefingers high point will be meeting with the Lords of the Vale. No Olena, no Jaqen. Arya’s story this season so far would be as much as they could fit. Don’t forget, we’d still have the Dornish characters and Greyjoy plots that are completely separate from the main so that would irritate people as we wouldn’t get to see the point of their stories until the end of the season and they wouldn’t cross over into main characters stories until season 6. There would be more characters who’s stories are separated so there would be a lot more jumping from character to character and there would not be as much plot moving forward as they have now with characters stories converged. This would be the worse season by FAR among the general public but ESPECIALLY with Unsullied.

        Quote  Reply

    9. I really enjoy the Anatomy of a Throne feature. It looks at the adaptation changes without a lot of emotion. Keep up the great work, Marc!

        Quote  Reply

    10. Great read again. I have to commend how you avoid writing from a purist or showfanatic point of view. You merely take two scenes, expand on the themes and the limitations of both media and pass judgement in a well argumented way. Have to agree that this scene works better in the show, in part due to Martin’s inability to write good sex scenes (nobody is perfect). Also agree with the people mentioning the lack of realism in the book’s Night’s Watch.

      Especially considering what is coming in the finale this season. I know the grudge of a lot of Watchmen is thoroughly touched upon in the books. I still feel their reason for being sent to the wall should have come to light more. You would think that for a lot of criminals, being sent to a frosty hellhole will make them only more bitter and dangerous. A big reason while I really thought the extra Craster’s Keep scenes were a success in my opinion

        Quote  Reply

    Jump to the Top

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *